#218 – The Most Important Trait

by | Mar 10, 2026 | Herd Quitter® Minute | 0 comments

When purchasing a bull, what is your most important trait? Most select for growth or carcass, but one of the most basic attributes of a bull is producing a live calf. “The weaning weight for dead calves is distressingly low” (Kit Pharo).

Click to read the full transcript

What is the most important trait that you select for when buying a bull? Do you look at the growth EPD’s, like weaning weight or yearling weight? You may look at carcass traits. Or maybe you are hung up on price, looking for a bargain in the midst of an all-time high cattle market.

Here’s something to think about: How about a bull that produces live calves? I know that seems like a no-brainer, and there is no EPD for that, but there is nothing worse at calving time than dead calves. Kit Pharo always says, “The weaning weights for dead calves are distressingly low.”

I became a PCC® customer thirteen years ago specifically for calving ease. I was out to prove that Kit Pharo was full of hot air about his guaranteed calving ease bulls. I bought two bulls and put them out with 60 head of heifers. The next spring, I stayed up all night so I’d be ready to pull calves like usual, but I never had to. I just watched as they laid down and calved all alone. I also saw that the calves were not stressed, encouraging them to get up and suck immediately. That resulted in healthier calves and heifers that quickly learned to be good moms. The only thing I didn’t like was feeling stupid for doing things the hard way all those years.

I’m not going to tell you that we never have calving problems, but it’s so rare that I now sleep through the night. This morning, I found two first calf heifers. with live calves that have already been up and sucked, without my help. That makes everybody happy, especially the bookkeeper. By the way, those guaranteed calving-ease bulls turned out to be the thickest, easiest keeping bulls I’ve ever had. I’m not saying that calving-ease is the most important trait, but producing a live calf seems to be toward the top of the list. I’ll see you next time on the Herd Quitter® Minute.

Get Updates via Email

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Latest from our Herd Quitter® Blog

The $30K Sofa

Dying Breed recently posted an article about the $30K sofa. A couple bought a $100 sofa in the 1950s and then had to redecorate their entire house to make everything else match. In the end, the husband figured the sofa cost him over $30K. How often do we see this...

read more

Good Foundation

If a cow or a bull has bad feet, it doesn’t matter what the rest of the animal looks like – and it doesn’t matter what the pedigree or EPDs look like. A cow or bull must have a good foundation to stand on to stay in production for more than just a few years....

read more