#205 – When to Cull Cows

by | Dec 2, 2025 | Herd Quitter® Minute | 3 comments

This time of year cowmen are making decisions on which cows to cull from their herd. Some of those decisions should be obvious. Don’t make excuses for problem cows.

Click to read the full transcript

This is the time of year when many cowmen are preg checking, aging and evaluating their cow herd. Many will add replacements and make decisions on which cows to cull.

According to Kit Pharo, some decisions are easy. A cow that does not produce a calf every year needs to go to town. This seems like a no-brainer, but it is amazing how many producers will give an open cow a second chance. She is dead weight – let her go!

You might be surprised how much late calving cows will cost you. A calf born at the end of your calving season vs. the beginning, will weigh significantly less and get sorted off from the group at sale time. Keep the cows that are the most fertile and cull late calvers.

Don’t make excuses for cows that always need help. Pulling calves, bad udders and fence crawlers are extra troubles you don’t need. A neighbor in Iowa had a cow that prolapsed her uterus every year. He laced her up afterward and removed it each spring so she could calve. I hope your time is more valuable than that. Cull the cows that make extra work!

Dangerous dispositions are another place where cows often get a pass. We make excuses for her like, “She sure is mean, but she always raises a good calf.” I put up with that nonsense back when I could run fast, but not anymore. It is not worth the risk. America needs hamburger – send her to town.

Old cows don’t have to be culled just because they reach a certain age. If she holds her condition and raises a good calf, why sell her? She is paid for, fully depreciated, and has earned her spot. It is not uncommon to find several teenage cows in PCC® herds. However, we do not give them special treatment – they need to pull their own weight.

Wally Olson offers another option, if you like developing heifers. He suggests selling cows at the top of their price appreciation, rather than keeping them for life. A heifer steadily grows in value from birth through age 5. From that point on, she will decline in value each year. Why not sell her when she’s worth the most instead of later when she’s worth the least? On the other hand, don’t discount the value of building longevity in your herd.

Don’t make excuses for your cow herd. Following these commonsense guidelines can build a profitable, low-maintenance cow herd. Buy your genetics from a seed stock producer who does the same. I’ll see you next time on the Herd Quitter® Minute.

Get Updates via Email

3 Comments

  1. Sterling Moore

    One of the most imformative “Herd quitter minutes” that I have listened to. Excellent. It covered many considerations on managing your cow herd. Thank you.

    Reply
    • Robert Pulliam

      Thank you, Sterling!

      Reply
  2. James A Welch

    America needs hamburger! Now, that’s a great line!

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Latest from our Herd Quitter® Blog

Returns

We live in a society that demands instant results. We often want the reward before we’ve even paid for it! Shane Parrish shared a similar thought in his weekly blog: "The universe does not offer financing. This is hard to accept because modern life trains us to expect...

read more

The Long Haul

If you plan to be in the cow-calf business for the long haul, you must be willing to change with the times. Nothing stays the same. The present is different from the past and the future will be different from the present. Today’s beef industry is not the same as it...

read more